Insurance questions, answered, in Stoughton, MA

You're our priority, whoever your insurer is.

Pick the question that fits. Each one jumps to a short, plain answer.

What do you need help with?

Please note: we aren't accepting repair work on claims through some insurance companies right now. Call us at (781) 344-5950 before you book, and we'll tell you whether we can take your claim.

Rental & Towing Coordination

If your car can't be driven, call Ace. We'll arrange a tow to the shop during our normal business hours. Need a car while yours is here? We have on-site rentals through Prime Rent-A-Car.

Wondering what your policy pays for a rental? See Helpful answer 3.

More on rental & towing

Had an Accident?

↑ Back to questions

Insurance Repair Guidance

You handle your claim with your insurance company. We handle your repair. We welcome your insurer's appraiser to inspect the vehicle at our shop, and we work directly with them on the repair estimate and any supplements, so your car is repaired properly.

We'll answer your questions about the repair side of your insurance claim.

Independent shop. Ace Auto Body is not affiliated with any insurance company or its preferred-shop programs. Our customer is you, the vehicle owner, and our job is to repair your vehicle properly.

More on insurance repair guidance

↑ Back to questions

Insurance Appraisal Help

Sometimes you and your own insurance company can't agree on how much it should cost to fix your car. Massachusetts auto policies usually include a step called "appraisal" for this kind of disagreement on a collision or comprehensive claim under your own policy. It generally doesn't apply when you're claiming against another driver's insurance company.

  • You or your insurance company can ask in writing for appraisers to be selected. Your policy sets the deadline for asking, so read it or ask your insurer or agent.
  • Each side chooses a competent, disinterested appraiser; the two appraisers choose an umpire; a written decision signed by any two sets the amount.
  • You pay your own appraiser and share the umpire's cost.

Source: M.G.L. c. 175, § 191A.

You stay in charge of your claim. We can't tell you whether to ask for appraisal.

How appraisal works

↑ Back to questions

Repair Records for Claim Disputes

  • We put our repair records and photos together in one place for you.
  • We keep you updated on your car while the disagreement is worked out.

More on repair records

↑ Back to questions

Helpful answers before you approve a repair

Here are short, general answers for Massachusetts drivers deciding where and how to repair a vehicle after an accident or other loss. Insurance policies differ by company and edition, and your own policy terms control. Review your policy and Coverage Selections Page, and ask your insurer or agent about your specific claim.

Do I have to use my insurance company's "preferred" or referral shop?

No. In Massachusetts, your insurance company and its appraiser can't require you to use a particular repair shop. They also can't request or suggest one. If your insurer has a referral-shop program, it may give you a list of registered shops and mark some of them as its referral shops.

Sources: M.G.L. c. 26, § 8G; 212 CMR 2.04(1)(c); 211 CMR 123.06.

Can I ask for original manufacturer (OEM) parts?

Yes, you can always ask. When your insurer is paying for repairs, Massachusetts rules generally call for new OEM parts in two cases. The first is when using a non-OEM part could affect how safely the vehicle operates. The second is when the vehicle has 20,000 miles or fewer, unless its condition before the accident warrants otherwise. Otherwise, the insurer's appraisal may use used, rebuilt, or aftermarket parts of "like kind and quality," meaning in equal or better condition than the part being replaced. If you want OEM parts where your insurer isn't required to pay for them, you can choose them and pay the difference. Any written estimate that uses non-OEM exterior body parts must identify those parts and include a state notice about them.

Sources: 211 CMR 133.04(1); M.G.L. c. 90, § 34R; Mass. Division of Insurance, Auto Insurance Claims FAQ.

Does my collision or comprehensive coverage pay for a rental car?

Not by itself. Collision and comprehensive pay to repair your vehicle. On your own policy, a rental is usually covered only if you bought optional Substitute Transportation coverage, and only up to the daily and total limits you selected.

Sources: M.G.L. c. 90, § 34O; Mass. Division of Insurance, Auto Insurance Claims FAQ.

If the accident wasn't my fault, do I still have to use my own insurance?

Not necessarily. You can usually make a claim with the at-fault driver's insurance company under that driver's property damage coverage. If you have your own collision or limited collision coverage, you can use that instead, which can get repairs started sooner. Your deductible generally applies, unless your policy includes a Waiver of Deductible endorsement and your accident meets its conditions (for example, your vehicle was legally parked, or it was rear-ended by an identified driver). Without that endorsement, your insurer isn't required to waive the deductible, whatever the fault finding.

If you claim with the other driver's insurance company, the appraisal clause in your own policy (your right to appraisal) doesn't apply to that claim. How appraisal works

Sources: M.G.L. c. 90, § 34O; M.G.L. c. 175, § 191A; Mass. Division of Insurance, Auto Insurance Claims FAQ.

If my vehicle is a total loss, does my insurer have to pay for a new one?

Generally, no. On a total loss under your own collision, limited collision, or comprehensive coverage, your insurer pays the vehicle's actual cash value as of the date of loss, minus your deductible. It does not pay what a new vehicle would cost. Actual cash value weighs several factors together:

  • the retail value of a similar vehicle in similar condition
  • what you paid, plus any improvements, less depreciation
  • any earlier unrelated damage the appraiser finds
  • what a comparable vehicle that's actually available would cost

You can ask your insurer which sources it used.

If you and your insurer can't agree on the amount, your policy includes an appraisal process. Either side can demand it in writing within the deadline in your policy. Each side picks an appraiser, the two appraisers choose an umpire, and a written award signed by any two of them sets the amount. This process applies only to your own policy's collision, limited collision, or comprehensive coverage. It does not apply to a claim against another driver's insurer.

Sources: 211 CMR 133.05(1); M.G.L. c. 175, § 191A; Mass. Division of Insurance, Auto Insurance Claims FAQ.

Insurer says your car may be a total loss?

Bring your car and your insurer's paperwork to us before you decide. We'll go over it with you, and the decision is yours.

Is my car a total loss? Your right to choose

We work for you, the vehicle owner, not the insurance company.

We take care of your repair, and you stay in charge of your claim.

↑ Back to questions

Back to top

You have the legal right to choose the body shop that repairs your vehicle.

Massachusetts law: M.G.L. c. 26, § 8G and 212 CMR 2.04(1)(c).

Your insurer may still inspect your vehicle and decide its payment under your policy. Optional discount endorsements may affect payment.

Send photos and a few details about the damage. We'll get back to you within one business day.